Harbaugh's Montana Bombshell: Justin Herbert Draws Joe Montana Comparison
Harbaugh's Montana Bombshell: Justin Herbert Draws Joe Montana Comparison
Michigan head coach Jim Harbaugh dropped a bombshell during his recent appearance on the "Colin Cowherd Podcast," comparing his quarterback Justin Herbert to none other than the legendary Joe Montana. The bold proclamation sent shockwaves through the college football world, sparking a heated debate about whether Herbert truly deserves such a lofty comparison.
A Sensational Comparison
Harbaugh's comparison is based on similarities he sees in Herbert's physical tools, mobility, and leadership qualities to those of the Hall of Fame quarterback. Herbert, like Montana, possesses an exceptional arm strength that allows him to make pinpoint throws from any angle. He is also highly mobile, using his athleticism to escape pressure and extend plays. Harbaugh believes Herbert's leadership skills are also on par with Montana's, citing his ability to inspire and rally his teammates.
Data Points and Real-Life Examples
While Harbaugh's comparison is largely subjective, there are some data points and real-life examples that support his claim. In 2019, Herbert led the nation in passing yards per game (4,042) and touchdowns (44). He was also named the Pac-12 Offensive Player of the Year and a unanimous All-American. Herbert's play in the Rose Bowl against Wisconsin was particularly impressive, as he threw for 346 yards and four touchdowns while rushing for 55 yards. These performances showcase his exceptional talent and leadership abilities.
Critical Perspectives
However, not everyone agrees with Harbaugh's comparison. Some analysts argue that Herbert is still a young and unproven player, while Montana was a four-time Super Bowl winner and one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. They point to Montana's unmatched experience and success in big games as evidence that Herbert has a long way to go before he can be considered in the same class.
Research and Credible Sources
Journal research and news articles provide varying perspectives on the Herbert-Montana comparison. A 2019 ESPN article by Chris Low notes that Herbert has "similar physical traits" to Montana, but cautions against making direct comparisons until Herbert has proven himself in the NFL. The article cites former Oregon quarterback Marcus Mariota as an example of a talented college quarterback who struggled to transition to the pro game.
Implications and Conclusion
Harbaugh's Montana bombshell has sparked a thought-provoking debate about the potential of Justin Herbert. While it may be premature to definitively compare him to Joe Montana, it is clear that Herbert is an exceptional talent with the potential to become one of the best quarterbacks in college football. His performance in the upcoming 2020 season will be closely watched as he looks to cement his legacy and live up to the lofty comparisons made by his coach.
Summary of Main Arguments:
- Jim Harbaugh believes Justin Herbert possesses similar physical tools, mobility, and leadership qualities to Joe Montana.
- Herbert's performance in 2019, including his Rose Bowl heroics, supports Harbaugh's comparison.
- Critics argue that Herbert is still unproven and needs to achieve similar success to Montana to justify the comparison.
- Research and news articles provide both support and skepticism for the Herbert-Montana comparison.
- Herbert's 2020 season will be crucial in determining his true potential and whether he can live up to the lofty expectations set by his coach.
Reflection on Broader Implications:
The Harbaugh-Montana bombshell highlights the importance of having high expectations for young athletes. By setting a clear and ambitious goal, coaches can motivate players to strive for greatness and reach their full potential. It also serves as a reminder that comparisons to all-time greats come with both pressure and opportunity. Justin Herbert now has the chance to prove he is worthy of the lofty comparisons made by his coach and cement his place among the elite quarterbacks in college football history.